top of page

A Summary of School Phone Policies: Can They Really Be Good or Bad?

Writer: Sadie Sonneborn Malecki
Sadie Sonneborn Malecki
10 minutes ago
4 min read

Many high school students have one thing in common: they carry a cell phone. In recent years, cell phones have grown more essential and prevalent in high school. Only a few decades ago,  the Pew Center Internet & American Life Project showed that roughly  45% of teenagers had cell phones. Jump 20 years into the future, and now around 95% of teenagers have or have access to a cellular device. This increase resulted in many questions, including: How do schools address this situation? Phones can be used in both advantageous and detrimental ways, so schools have had to adapt, developing restrictive policies and regulations around phone usage. There are supporters and opponents of these methods; however, is there one inherent right answer? Today’s summary will give evidence for and against each argument, hopefully validating or contradicting one’s own opinions on the issue.

Starting with the for stance, schools implement phone regulations for a few many reasons. The biggest one is reducing distractions to foster in-class participation and discussion. In more classrooms than before, teachers face similar situations: they will be teaching a lesson, but all they see are the tops of students’ heads because they are scrolling, texting, or engaging with their phones. This can discourage teachers and other students who want to engage with the material, and is detrimental to students on their phones, as they miss crucial coursework. In simple terms, phones are distracting. Studies have found that even “[s]tudents with their phones next to them, either on the table or in bags, did worse and were more likely to report thinking about whether they had been messaged.” Beyond simply being a temptation in the back of students' minds, drawing them in like a child with a candy bar, phones have longer-term effects on students' participation and engagement, as according to a report by the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO), “a single cell phone notification causes students to lose focus for an average of 20 minutes.” Together, irresistible temptations and the brain's active response to simple notifications have led teachers to support rules against phones in schools. 

In addition to personal effects in the classroom, schools are aware of phones’ detriments outside the room. Before phones were considered an issue, schools faced a bigger dilemma: bullying. Unfortunately, phones in teenagers’ lives have not alleviated this issue; they have actually increased it. Social media and quick messaging platforms have introduced a new wave of cyberbullying, as spreading “the word” has rapidly increased at the click of a button. This unlimited online connection via social media and messaging platforms has resulted in serious damage; as the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) states, it is “...associated with a higher prevalence of bullying victimization at school and electronically, persistent feelings of sadness or hopelessness, and some suicide risk among students (considering attempting suicide and having made a suicide plan), both overall and in stratified models.” Overall, this increase in bullying and worse mental health has persuaded schools to implement regulations to reduce phone use.

There is another side to the story, though. A significant number of people disagree with the policies established in nearly two-thirds of K-12 schools, as Melissa Kay Diliberti and colleagues note.

To begin, many parents get their child a phone for a simple reason: communication. Being able to text, call, FaceTime, or easily contact one’s own child is incredibly important. When schools implement restrictions, though, some parents and guardians feel that their child’s inability to contact them is not valid, as they cannot guarantee their safety during the day. This is also a majority opinion, as data from the National Parents Union states the main reason parents oppose phone policies is “[s]o that [their] child can use their phone if there is an emergency at school 78%.” That is over two-thirds of parents who advocate for phone policy removals because safety is of utmost importance to them, and rules on their children’s access to phones directly inhibit their trust in the school because of safety concerns. 

Another argument against school policies is that phones are the future, and schools should be teaching students relevant information for the future. As soon as the bell rings, students have access to their phones. They do everyday tasks on them. They communicate on them. They use them in unique ways to grow their intellectual curiosity about the world. For some individuals, this is the start of a perfect argument for how schools should address phones: by developing phone literacy programs. Rather than avoiding phones altogether, Brandon Cardet-Hernandez, an educator for Education Week, a national K–12 education news publication, argues that working with phones and other online tools may create better circumstances for students and faculty, as they “...allow students to remain engaged for longer periods of time, progress their learning journeys at an individualized pace, and free up valuable teacher time for small-group instruction and social-emotional learning.” Ultimately, by embracing phones instead of restricting them, students can gain valuable life skills, and faculty can maintain control over phone usage.

School phone policies are becoming more visible than before. Whether in elementary, middle, or high school, new phone restrictions are being created to shape students' experiences. Many people see this as both positive and negative, meaning it is important to weigh all available information. All in all, phone policies have an impact, and like anything that can change the way humanity thinks, acts, or is, society should stay aware of them.


Comments


bottom of page